
PAGE 58 EC COMPETITION POLICY NEWSLETTER Vol. 1, N° 2, Summer 1994
and reasonably efficient enforcement procedures. It is in this
context that DG IV and the competent authorities of the
relevant countries began drawing up such rules within the
Joint Committees set up under each of the Interim
Agreements. The first draft has been drawn up jointly by DG
IV and the Polish Antimonopoly Office. The draft was
submitted to the Joint Committee under the Community-
Poland Interim Agreement and approved in January 1994. It
is currently in the process of being reconfirmed in the
framework of the Europe Agreement. Further drafts have
recently been agreed upon by DG IV and the responsible
Bulgarian, Hungarian and Slovak authorities and are being
submitted to the relevant organs of the Interim Europe
Agreements for approval. Negotiations with the other
countries are far advanced and it is hoped that finalization of
the texts will take place before the end of this year.
The main instrument for dealing with cases that fall foul of
the competition provisions are the Community competition
rules on the one hand, and the national competition laws of
the respective countries on the other hand. Both authorities
apply their own laws but they are linked through a
cooperation procedure. For DG IV this will mean that it will
have to take account of those Agreements in the definition
of its priorities of action. On the other hand such tools as
Regulation 17 do not obtain wider applicability than before.
The implementing rules deal with three situations:
- Situations may arise in which each authority (DG IV and
the authority of the respective associated country) may
have jurisdiction in one and the same case.
- In other cases where only one authority is competent, the
measures taken by it may affect major interests of the
party whose national authority is not competent.
- Finally, a case might fall outside the competence of the
authorities of both parties.
In cases falling under the competence of both competition
authorities, starting point has been to ensure close
cooperation between those authorities. A one-stop-shop
principle (as for instance in the EEA Agreement between the
Commission and the EFTA Surveillance Authority) was not
considered workable in this particular context, because of the
lacking element of a "supranational" second pillar and an
independent Court to ensure its control, which is foreseen in
the EEA Agreement. Rather, the approach chosen is similar
to that under the 1991 EC-US Agreement and also contains
some elements borrowed from the 1986 OECD
recommendation. Notifications of cases, requests for
information and consultations are foreseen between the
authorities, as well as a recourse to the principles of negative
and positive comity. This means that the authority of the
other party can be requested to exercise restraint in the
application of its laws, or even to take positive action with
respect to certain practices affecting the requesting party's
important interests. Possible conflicts should only be brought
to the Joint Committee as a last resort.
Similar proceedings are foreseen in cases where only one
authority is competent. It is here that one can imagine that
positive comity will have a large role to play, if interests of
the party whose competition authority is not competent for
a given case are at stake.
Cases of so-called negative conflict of competence, i.e.
falling outside the competence of the authorities of both
parties, are difficult to imagine, given that it is sufficient for
an agreement to produce effects or to be implemented in the
Community for the Community to have jurisdiction, and
since most of the laws of the associated countries have also
embraced the effects doctrine. Nevertheless it is provided
that such cases can be discussed in the Joint Committee,
without prejudice to the rights of EC Member States.
Some further points of interest in the implementing rules
concern a "de minimis" rule, consultations in merger control
matters and confidentiality. The rules also provide that the
principles of EC block exemptions shall be taken over by
the associated countries.
b) Rules related to state aids
The definition of implementing rules relating to state aids
and their control in a transparent way is an area which will
be requiring immediate attention in the near future. While
none of the associated countries have the budgetary means
to pay large subsidies, there are a variety of support
mechanisms such as tax reliefs, non pursuit of debts owed to
the state etc. which are classified as state aids in the
Community. Work has already begun in that the associated
countries have agreed that as a first step towards
transparency an inventory of existing aids needs to be drawn
up. For this task they benefit from technical assistance
provided by PHARE.
The implementing rules will need to define methods of
mutual cooperation, taking into account the particular
situation of the associated countries as economies in
transition. It is to be noted that the Agreement already
provides for the application of the article 92(3,a) derogation
from the basic interdiction to give aid.
It is generally felt that state aid control is an area which will
require a special effort in training and technical assistance.
For an effective enforcement, achieving a conversion of
mentality and creating an awareness of the problem will
probably be as important as putting in place the formal rules.
2) Relations with the Newly Independent States
a) Baltic States
In relation with the three Baltic States (Estonia, Latvia,
Lithuania), negotiations of Free Trade Agreements have
recently been concluded. They contain competition rules
similar to those in the Europe Agreements concluded with
the CEEC.
b) Russia
In the Partnership and Cooperation Agreement (PCA) signed
with Russia
in June, competition provisions are likewise
included. Given that the links established between the
Community and Russia are different in nature and not as far-
reaching as with the CEEC and the Baltic States, the
competition rules agreed upon in this context are less
stringent.
Comentarios a estos manuales